When I moved from Lacey, Washington to Virginia Beach 10 months ago, one of the reasons I was excited about the move was the
opportunity to be in the middle of everything. Being up in the that left hand corner pretty much limits your spur of the moment trips to Spokane, Portland, or a very long, harsh, unforgiving drive to California.
Being in the mid-atlantic, I have a fairly short drive to Washington DC, Baltimore, Boston — and of course, New York. Using an internet map service, it’s about a nine hour drive to Cooperstown, New York — home of the Baseball Hall Of Fame. I have put off this trip for various reasons (gas prices, laziness, school, laziness) — but it occured to me about a month ago that I could make my first trip during the 2010 introduction ceremonies, and maybe just maybe get a chance to see Edgar Martinez inducted into the most sacred of baseball grounds.
Unfortunately, if you take the current yes vs no collection up at Ussmariner.com (which is outstanding, by the way) as a poll, Martinez is going to fall far short of the 75 percent requirement. In this — the age of the internet — we not only get to find out who, what, where or when faster than ever, we find out the why, and in much more detail than ever before. Many of the voters have given their reasoning as to why they think that Martinez doesn’t belong in the Hall Of Fame, stating their various expectations for who belongs and what their standards are for someone to be invited to Cooperstown.
The reasoning for some of these baseball ‘experts’ for not including Edgar on their ballots is embarassing. For these writers to be so un-educated on the game and to be allowed to decide something so important makes me wonder if it’s as important as I once thought.
Here are a few of the more common reasons Edgar is being left of ballots
He spent most of his career as a DH: Ok, Bruce Sutter and Goose Gossage spent most of his career pitching with two to three run leads for one inning. Yet Gossage made it without any controversy It doesn’t even matter why Edgar was a DH, the numbers he put up at any position are insane. Martinez career OPS is .933, currently 33rd best of any hitter to ever play the game. Nine times Edgar Martinez finished in the top 10 of adjusted OPS. Of the ridiculously high number players who qualify, Edgar Martinez ranks 38th. Thats higher than Ken Griffey, Jr, Tony Gwynn, Wade Boggs, George Brett, and some OF named DiMaggio. The idea that since he did it as a designated hitter it means less is just laughable. Run prevention is great, but its impossible to win without players getting on base and producing extra base hits, and there’s not a single right-handed hitter who did it better than Edgar in the 90’s or half of the 00’s.
He didn’t hit any of the major milestones : This is probably the most frustrating argument you’ll hear not only for this year, but for years to follow. Apparently to some voters you can just ignore players until they hit 500 homers or 3000 hits or 300 wins or bla, bla, bla. Yes, Edgar never got to 3000 hits, but he did get on base 42 perecent of the time. Appearantly, since Eddie Murray got 3000 hits and 500 home runs, it doesn’t matter that he got on base 5 percent less than Martinez and had an OPS 50 points lower. What matters is that he played a position and that he had a lot more at bats. Because thats the key to winning baseball games, not scoring more runs than the other team, but batting more times than the other team. Excuse me while I try to remove the hammer from my brain. Why is it counted against Edgar thath e walked nearly 1300 times? We teach our kids a walk is as good as a hit, and then dont vote for a guy who gets on base 3400 times because not enough of them are…hits. Excuse me while I remove the hammer from my head.
He played in the PED period: Fine, but you better not vote for anyone from this era either. No Pujols, no Manny Ramirez, no A-Rod, none. Having a low (albeit growing) percentage of the league screw up and cheat doesnt mean you should hold it against Martinez. Numbers are numbers. The fact that Edgar slugged .515 for 17 seasons has nothing to do with who injected who and never should. If you don’t think players who test positive for steroids or any other performance-enhancing drug should be allowed to make the Hall Of Fame, fine. Putting everyone else who played in the era on the same level is childish.
And finally, and this is the one that makes my brain really hurt
I just never got the feeling that Edgar was a Hall Of Famer, but maybe I’ll vote for him at a later time: I honestly didn’t know what to say when I first started writing this. I probably wrote and erased about three-hundred times til I finally came to this conclusion:
You dont deserve your vote . If you truly are being paid to be considered an expert at the sport, and you really did the research, and the end-result was hmmm, not now, but maybe next time — go away.
Same to you Dan Shaughnessy, for saying ridiculous things like “Some guys just strike you as Cooperstown-worthy and others do not. Edgar Martinez was a very fine hitter, but I never said to myself, “The Mariners are coming to Fenway this weekend. I wonder how the Sox are going to pitch to Edgar Martinez?”
This guy gets to decide who gets in the Hall Of Fame? Someone who bases his vote on how he, someone who has absolutely nothing to do with the game, feels about how pitchers are going to pitch to him?
Or how about this winner from Jon Heyman
“While Martinez was a superb hitter, and his career .418 on-base percentage and .515 slugging percentages are impressive indeed, only twice did Martinez even crack the top 10 in MVP voting (he was third once and sixth once). That suggests something less than dominance. And even on his career totals, he comes up short. His final power figures (309 home runs, 1,261 RBIs) are underwhelming for someone whose whole candidacy is based on offense.”
Yes folks. The entire object of the game of baseball is to hit home runs, hope that someone is on base before you bat, and pray that you do it well enough to be in the top ten in MVP voting.
And this whole “he’s not a Hall Of Famer now but he might be in 2028″ argument is just baffling. Nothing changes. Edgar’s stat line will still read 300/400/500. There will still be an extremely small amount of players who can ever come close to those numbers. What in the world changes from year to year, other than perhaps youre ability to comprehend statistics.
I just dont get it. I hope this entire post was just an exercise in ranting and that Edgar gets in convincingly. It doesn’t look very likely though, and that should make not only Mariner fans sad, but anyone who appreciates greatness.
Edgar was great, its a shame that only half of the country seems to understand.